What counts as unaffordable catalogue lending
A catalogue or shopping account lets you buy now and pay over time, with interest on the balance. It works like a credit card for one retailer or group of retailers, so the same lending rules apply.
The provider had to check the opening limit was affordable and check again before significant increases. Claims usually involve limits that crept up, sometimes with a “good news” letter, while the balance stayed close to the limit.
- Apr 2014Under the FCA’s rules, catalogue credit providers must assess whether you can afford the credit before opening an account or significantly raising the limit.
- Nov 2018More detailed rules on affordability checks, including looking at income and essential outgoings.
- Dec 2018Catalogue and store card providers must not raise the credit limit for customers at risk of financial difficulty. From March 2019 customers had to be given control over limit increases.
- Jun 2019Persistent debt rules extended to catalogue accounts: providers must step in after 18 months of paying more in interest and charges than off the balance.
Signs you could have a claim
- 01Your limit kept going upSeveral increases in a short time, especially unasked, are a common feature of upheld complaints.
- 02Your balance was always close to the limitA balance that never came down suggested you were relying on the account.
- 03You only ever made the minimum paymentYears of minimum payments mean you paid mostly interest.
- 04You used it for essentialsClothes for the children, bedding or appliances you couldn’t otherwise afford point to financial difficulty.
- 05You had other debts or missed paymentsProblems on your credit file were visible when the provider raised your limit.
What you could get back
Interest on unaffordable lendingRefunded
Fees and chargesRefunded
Interest on your refundAdded
Missed payment markersRemoved
If a complaint is upheld, the provider usually removes interest and charges on the part of the balance above the last fair limit, from the date of the unfair increase.
If you still owe money, the refund reduces the balance first. Anything left over is paid to you with interest added.
Ombudsman decisions on catalogue complaints
Published Financial Ombudsman decisions show how these complaints are judged. Every complaint is decided on its own facts, so these are examples, not a guide to what you’ll get.
-
UpheldLittlewoods
The opening limit and first three increases were fair, but Littlewoods limit increases from March 2021 were irresponsible.
Read decision DRN-6011343 -
Partly upheldJD Williams
The limit was raised seven times, from £175 to £1,500, in just over a year. The last increase should not have been made because the customer had already started missing payments.
Read decision DRN-3173135 -
Not upheldVery
Not upheld beyond the lender’s own offer to remove interest on balances above £2,650.
Read decision DRN-4630785
Catalogue and shopping accounts we cover
Each page sets out who provides the credit, published ombudsman decisions about that lender, and how to complain to it.
Catalogue claim questions
Is a catalogue account the same as a credit card?
For lending purposes, yes. It’s a running account with a limit and interest, so the same affordability rules apply.
I have accounts with several brands. Do I complain to each?
Check who provides the credit. Several brands can belong to one provider, and one complaint can cover all of them.
Can I claim if the account is closed?
Yes. Closed accounts can still be looked at, subject to the time limits.
What about buy now pay later on my catalogue account?
Buy now pay later offers on a catalogue account are part of a regulated credit account, so they’re covered. Since March 2019 providers have had to explain them clearly and remind you before the offer period ends.
How far back can I claim?
Usually six years from the lending, or three years from when you realised you had cause to complain, whichever is later.
How to complain about a catalogue account yourself
You can complain to the credit provider directly and for free. Say which account and when the limit increases happened, and ask for them to be reviewed for affordability.
The provider has eight weeks to reply. If you’re unhappy with the answer, or it hasn’t replied in time, you can take it to the Financial Ombudsman, normally within six months of the final response. That’s free too.
Sources
- FCA CP18/43: high-cost credit review (catalogue credit, store cards and home credit)
- Financial Ombudsman: how it handles unaffordable lending complaints
- Financial Ombudsman: unaffordable lending (consumer guide)
- FCA PS18/19: assessing creditworthiness in consumer credit
- FCA Handbook DISP 2.8: time limits for taking a complaint to the ombudsman