What counts as unaffordable payday loan lending
Payday and short-term loans are high-cost credit: small amounts over days or months, at high interest. Because they’re expensive, the lender had to be sure you could repay without borrowing again or falling behind on bills.
Most claims are about the pattern rather than one loan. Borrowing again soon after repaying, having loans running at the same time, or each loan being bigger than the last can all show the lending had stopped being sustainable. A lender can be wrong to keep lending even if each repayment looked small.
- Apr 2014Under the FCA’s rules, lenders must check you can afford each loan, and a loan can’t be rolled over more than twice. Lenders shouldn’t let you take loan after loan if the combined effect is unsustainable.
- Jan 2015Price cap: interest and fees capped at 0.8% a day, a £15 cap on default fees, and you never repay more than double what you borrowed.
- Nov 2018More detailed rules on affordability checks, including income and essential outgoings.
Signs you could have a claim
- 01You borrowed again soon after repayingA new loan within days of clearing the last one suggests you needed to borrow to get through the month.
- 02You had several loans running at onceOverlapping loans from the same lender, or from several, are a strong sign of financial difficulty.
- 03Each loan was bigger than the lastRising amounts over time can show growing reliance on credit rather than a one-off need.
- 04You borrowed over a long periodMonths or years of short-term borrowing is something the ombudsman treats as potentially harmful in itself.
- 05You had defaults or missed paymentsProblems on your credit file when you applied were visible to the lender.
What you could get back
Interest and chargesRefunded
Interest on your refundAdded
Balance owedReduced
Negative credit file entriesRemoved
For each loan found unaffordable, you usually only repay what you borrowed. Interest and charges you paid above that come back to you, with interest added.
Where the pattern of lending was the problem, negative information about those loans is usually removed from your credit file. If you still owe money, refunds reduce the balance first.
Ombudsman decisions on payday loan complaints
Published Financial Ombudsman decisions show how these complaints are judged. Every complaint is decided on its own facts, so these are examples, not a guide to what you’ll get.
-
Partly upheldQuidMarket
Four of six loans were irresponsible because of existing debt and signs of financial difficulty.
Read decision DRN-5527945 -
Partly upheldLending Stream
The third of three loans was irresponsible: the borrower had several loans running, defaults on file and was likely dependent on this type of credit.
Read decision DRN-4305287 -
Not upheldCash ASAP
A £250 loan was found affordable.
Read decision DRN-4511493
Payday and short-term lenders we cover
Each page sets out who provides the credit, published ombudsman decisions about that lender, and how to complain to it.
Payday loan claim questions
Can I claim if I paid every loan back on time?
Yes. Repaying on time doesn’t mean the loans were affordable: many people repay by borrowing again or by falling behind on other bills.
What if the lender has gone bust?
You can’t usually get a refund from a lender that has collapsed, unless it set up a redress scheme. Several big payday lenders have closed. Our lender pages only cover lenders that are still trading.
Does it matter that each loan was small?
Not necessarily. The ombudsman looks at the whole pattern, and a long run of small loans can still be unaffordable.
What if my loan was sold to a debt collector?
You still complain to the lender that made the decision to lend.
How far back can I claim?
Usually six years from each loan, or three years from when you realised you had cause to complain, whichever is later.
How to complain about a payday loan yourself
You can complain to the lender directly and for free. List the loans you took, if you can, and say you want them reviewed for affordability. Our lender pages link to each lender’s complaints page.
The lender has eight weeks to reply. If you’re unhappy with the answer, or it hasn’t replied in time, you can take it to the Financial Ombudsman, normally within six months of the final response. That’s free too.
Sources
- FCA: price cap rules for payday lenders confirmed
- Financial Ombudsman: payday loans
- Financial Ombudsman: how it handles unaffordable lending complaints
- Financial Ombudsman: unaffordable lending (consumer guide)
- FCA PS18/19: assessing creditworthiness in consumer credit
- FCA Handbook DISP 2.8: time limits for taking a complaint to the ombudsman