What counts as unaffordable personal loan lending
A personal loan is a fixed amount repaid in instalments, usually over one to five years. The lender had to check the repayments were affordable for the whole term, not just the first month.
Claims are most common with higher-cost lenders, where interest can be several times the amount borrowed, and with loans taken to pay off other debts. Consolidation loans often leave people worse off if the old debts aren’t closed.
- Apr 2014Under the FCA’s rules, lenders must check you can afford a loan before agreeing it. The more you borrow and the longer the term, the more thorough the checks should be.
- Nov 2018More detailed rules: lenders must look at your income and essential outgoings, and whether you can repay without borrowing more or falling behind on bills.
- OmbudsmanYou had to be able to repay without undue difficulty, while meeting your other commitments and without borrowing more. A loan can be unaffordable even if you never missed a payment.
Signs you could have a claim
- 01The repayments took a big share of your incomeIn upheld Bamboo Loans and Lendable decisions, the new loan would have taken debt repayments to around 40% of income.
- 02You borrowed to pay off other debtsA consolidation loan only helps if the old debts are cleared. If they weren’t, the lender should have checked.
- 03You already had defaults or missed paymentsProblems on your credit file when you applied were visible to the lender.
- 04You went back for a top-up or a new loanRefinancing before the first loan was paid off can show the borrowing was becoming a cycle.
- 05Your bank statements showed warning signsGambling, payday loans or returned payments were there to be seen if the lender looked.
What you could get back
Interest and chargesRefunded
Interest on your refundAdded
Balance owedReduced
Negative credit file entriesRemoved
If a loan is found unaffordable, you usually only repay what you borrowed. Anything you paid above that comes back to you, with interest added.
If you still owe money, the refund comes off the balance first, and the lender should agree an affordable way to repay the rest.
Ombudsman decisions on personal loan complaints
Published Financial Ombudsman decisions show how these complaints are judged. Every complaint is decided on its own facts, so these are examples, not a guide to what you’ll get.
-
UpheldBamboo Loans
The loan would have taken debt repayments to nearly 40% of income, and the borrower already had a County Court Judgment and was using an overdraft.
Read decision DRN-4074489 -
UpheldLendable
A £6,000 loan over 36 months would have taken debt repayments above 40% of the borrower’s income.
Read decision DRN-3818582 -
UpheldNatWest
NatWest accepted its checks on a £5,000, five-year loan were inadequate: proper checks would have shown the borrower was a student without a job. It refunded interest and charges, removed negative credit file entries and agreed a repayment plan for the rest.
Read decision DRN-5008578 -
Not upheldLikely Loans
A Likely Loans complaint where the lending was found affordable.
Read decision DRN-4149488
Personal loan lenders we cover
Each page sets out who provides the credit, published ombudsman decisions about that lender, and how to complain to it.
Personal loan claim questions
Can I claim if I’ve paid the loan off?
Yes. Repaid loans can still be looked at, subject to the time limits.
I took the loan to clear other debts. Can I still claim?
Yes. The lender still had to check the new repayments were affordable. The ombudsman looks at whether the lender could reasonably expect the loan to leave you better off.
Does a high-street bank loan count?
Yes. Any lender had to check affordability, including high-street banks. Most credit union loans fall outside these rules.
What if my loan was sold to a debt collector?
You still complain to the lender that made the decision to lend.
How far back can I claim?
Usually six years from the loan, or three years from when you realised you had cause to complain, whichever is later.
How to complain about a personal loan yourself
You can complain to the lender directly and for free. Say which loan, when you took it, and that you want it reviewed for affordability.
The lender has eight weeks to reply. If you’re unhappy with the answer, or it hasn’t replied in time, you can take it to the Financial Ombudsman, normally within six months of the final response. That’s free too.